Examples of Unnecessary Moves
Unnecessary Moves are a level 24 convention.
The Unnecessary Trash Push
Example 1
- All of the 2's are played on the stacks.
- Alice clues number 1 to Cathy, touching a single 1 on her chop. Since all of the 1's are already played, it is globally known that this must be some kind of Trash Push.
- Bob sees that the pushed card is a red 3. Cathy has no other red cards in her hand, so Alice could have just clued red to Cathy instead of doing a complicated Trash Push.
- Thus, Bob knows that this is an Unnecessary Trash Push. Bob blind-plays his Finesse Position card as an Ignition. It is the blue 3 and it successfully plays.
- Cathy knows that this must be a Trash Push Finesse on blue 4. Cathy blind-plays her slot 4 card, but it is red 3 instead and it successfully plays.
- Cathy now knows that since the two cards did not connect to each other, this must have been an Unnecessary Trash Push.
Example 2
- See the example image below.
- Alice can clue red to Bob in order to get the red 3 to play. Nothing is "blocking" the clue.
- Instead, Alice clues green to Bob as a Trash Push.
- Bob knows that this is a Trash Push, so he blind-plays his slot 1 card. It is a red 3 and it successfully plays.
- Cathy sees that this Trash Push was unnecessary. So, Cathy blind-plays her Finesse Position card as an Ignition. It is a yellow 1 and it successfully plays.
The Unnecessary Trash Push Finesse
- See the example image below.
- Alice can clue yellow to Cathy in order to perform a Finesse on the yellow 3 into the yellow 4.
- Instead, Alice clues red to Cathy as a Trash Push.
- Bob knows that this is a Trash Push and that the Trash Pushed card is a one-away-from-playable yellow 4. Thus, this must be a Trash Push Finesse that is calling for the yellow 3.
- Bob blind-plays his Finesse Position card. It is a yellow 3 and it successfully plays.
- Cathy plays the yellow 4.
- Donald sees that this Trash Push was unnecessary. So, Donald blind-plays his Finesse Position card as an Ignition. It is a green 4 and it successfully plays.
The Unnecessary Trash Bluff (with a Trash Push)
- See the example image below.
- Alice clues number 1 to Donald on a blue 1.
- Bob knows that from Donald's perspective, Alice's clue looks like a Play Clue on an unplayed 1. Donald will go on to misplay the blue 1.
- Thus, Bob knows that this is a Trash Finesse or Trash Bluff. He blind-plays his Finesse Position card. It is a blue 2 and it successfully plays.
- Cathy knows that all Trash Bluffs are unnecessary. She also sees that the unnecessary component will be a Trash Push instead of a Chop Move (since the blue 1 was on Donald's chop). Cathy plays her previously known red 1.
- Donald also knows that Trash Bluffs are to be treated as unnecessary. Donald blind-plays his slot 1 card to fulfill the "extra" component of the Unnecessary Trash Bluff. It is a red 2 and it successfully plays.
The Unnecessary Unknown Trash Discharge (with a Trash Push)
- See the example image below.
- Alice can clue number 4 to Bob in order to get the blue 4 to play. Nothing is "blocking" the clue.
- Instead, Alice clues red to Donald, touching a trash red 1.
- Bob knows that from Donald's perspective, Alice's clue looks like a Play Clue on the red 4. Donald will go on to misplay the red 1 as a red 4.
- If Bob plays his Finesse Position and it successfully plays, then that will not resolve the situation — Donald will then go on to think that the red card is red 5, which is not true.
- Thus, Bob knows that this must be an Unknown Trash Discharge. Bob blind-plays his Third Finesse Position. It is a blue 4 and it successfully plays.
- Cathy sees that the Unknown Trash Discharge was unnecessary. She also sees that the unnecessary component will be a Trash Push instead of a Chop Move (since the red 1 was on Donald's chop). Cathy plays her previously known green 4.
- Donald also sees that the Unknown Trash Discharge was unnecessary. Donald blind-plays his slot 2 card to fulfill the "extra" component of the Unnecessary Unknown Trash Discharge. It is a yellow 1 and it successfully plays.